White Street Pizza | Key West
1110 White Strret, Key West, Florida
(305) 735-4449
Nestled in the heart of the island, White Street Pizza has quickly become a beloved local favorite for gourmet brick-oven pies, comforting Italian classics, and a warm neighborhood vibe. Known for its exceptional dough and fresh fior di latte mozzarella, the menu features standout red and white pies—ranging from classic Margherita to local twists like the Key West Pink Shrimp pizza. Savor hearty pasta dishes, house-made meatballs, complemented by a carefully curated selection of beer and wine. Whether grabbing a table in the intimate dining room or ordering a post-beach takeout pie, this cozy spot delivers a true taste of paradise.
What people are saying:
”My mom and I decided to grab 4 appetizers to share while my fiancé went for the simple yet delicious pepperoni pizza (you just can’t go wrong) my favorite was the Marinated Beef Tips while my mom loved the Grilled Watermelon Salad 🍉. Definitely a new hidden gem!”
- Katherine B
“The best pizza place in Key West by far!!! My family and I had different pizza and they were all amazing! The crust is as thin as authentic Italian pizza and every pizza selection is very unique! I really love the detail of the fresh basil on top because that’s how it’s eaten in Italy as well. I would recommend 100%”
- Sebastián E
Hours: Monday through Friday 11am-9pm
Saturday 5-10pm, Sunday 5-9pm
An all-in-one Key West vacation package!
You’ll receive a Key West Bar Card for free drinks in Key West, Florida, a Key West Restaurant Card and a Backstage Pass Card at our lowest price! Order all 3 cards and receive 20% off your order!
Cards are valid for the card holder only. There is a signature strip on each card where you can print the card holder’s name. Orders are processed every Monday, Wednesday and Friday and typically take 5 business days to arrive.
www.KeyWestBarCard.com/FAQ
CLICK HERE TO GO TO YOUR CART.